Alexander A Bukhvostov, Anton S Dvornikov, Kirill V Ermakov and Dimitry A Kuznetsov*
Interfaculty Cellular and Molecular Oncology Research Group, School of Medicine, N. I. Pirogoff Russian National Research Medical University, 1 Ostrovityanov St., Moscow 119997, Russian Federation
Received date: April 21, 2017; Accepted date: September 30, 2017; Published date: October 11, 2017
Citation: Bukhvostov AA, Dvornikov AS, Ermakov KV, Kuznetsov DA (2017) Retinoblastoma Case: Shall We Get A Paramagnetic Trend in Chemotherapy? Arch Can Res Vol.5:No.4:158.
We have performed our study on a NEN-treated RB cell culture derived from a real clinical autopsy material. 3.5- year-old male donor has died of a massive complex abdominal trauma being previously RB-diagnosed with NMR and ultrasound tests, tumor located behind the eye globe equator line.
This is a first report ever on magnetic isotope effects of metal ions to cause the clear anti-cancer consequences in retinoblastoma cells by depriving them of the DNA repair capabilities. Both molecular mechanism of phenomenon and its possible meaning for retinoblastoma chemotherapy are presented here.
Retinoblastoma; Paramagnetics; Chemotherapy
RB: Retinoblastoma; DNApolB: DNA Polymerases Beta; MIE: Magnetic Isotope Effect; NEN: N– Ethyl–Melamide; NMR: Nuclear Magnetic Resonance; AML: Acute Myeloblast Leukemia.
DNA Polymerases Beta (DNApolB, EC 18.104.22.168) are the key players in DNA repair scenario which makes them critical for malignant cell survival mechanism [1,2]. This also makes them legitimate targets for pharmacologically promising inhibitors  including paramagnetic (magnetic, in brief) bivalent metal ions, (nMe2+) [4,5]. Being capable to promote the magnetic isotope effects (MIE) in vivo and in vitro these ions could be employed to “turn off” DNApolB to limit the tumor growth [6,7]. Particularly, retinoblastoma (RB) is an appropriate object for such an impact due to the DNA repair engaging paths of epigenetic control revealed in this peculiar cancer . To find out the in situ degree and validity of an impact like that, all cellular DNA polymerase species except for the beta ones (i.e., alpha, gamma and delta) might be selectively suppressed by N–ethyl–melamide (NEM) . Investigating a potential of the [nMe2+] MIE-Chemotherapeutic approach.
We have performed our study on a NEN-treated RB cell culture derived from a real clinical autopsy material. Some prophetic predictions regarding a therapeutic validity of epigenic DNA expression control in retinoblastoma (RB) has been publicized lately  and then confirmed considering the cancer DNA repair machinery as a target once its key part, DNA Polymerase Beta, overexpressed [2,7]. However, being predominantly based on experiments with RB cell lines like WERI-RB or Y79, this statement still may be treated as “immature” since the in vivo operating neuro-immune and neuro-endocrine paths are no doubt capable of making an impact on intracellular epigenetic environment. This means a necessity to verify the DNApolB related findings on a donor derived RB specimen. To fit this requirement, we have investigated both cell viability and the DNApolB function in a departed patient’s RB cells in culture subjected to such DNApolB effectors as the paramagnetic stable metal isotopes.
A unilateral solitary 12.5 mm RB (2A) was taken to prepare and maintain this cancer cell culture as described in method for preparation of culture of human retina pigment epithelium cells . 3.5 year old male donor has died of a massive complex abdominal trauma being previously RB-diagnosed with NMR and ultrasound tests, tumor located behind the eye globe equator line. 8 hrs after the death, an eye was enucleated. A verified parental assent was taken as ordered by an Article 47 of the Russian Federal Law # 323-FZ of 01.01.2017. Both routine confocal images and MTT data were applied to elucidate the viability of cells estimating the LC50 (µg/mL) values [10,11]. In 12 hrs 37°C pre–incubated samples, NEN was added to 0.5 mM for a complete suppression of all but Beta DNA Polymerase species . 6 hrs after, the nascent DNA were labeled with [Methyl-1,2-3H] dTTP, 180-220 Ci/ mmol, 100 µCi per 1.0 mL culture. The resulting NEN-resistant ([3H]DNA cpm/mg protein) values were considered as the in situ DNApolB specific activity patterns according to Bukhvostov et al. [5,9]. All protein measurements, DNA extraction, DNApolB catalytic activity determination, standard DNA 1.8%- agarose gel electrophoresis followed by the DNA chain size range estimate were carried out as described in analytical techniques in biochemistry and molecular biology  and modified it.
The results listed in Table 1 shows that the RB cells are extremely sensitive to all three MIE-promoters (25Mg2+, 43Ca2+, 67Zn2+) leading to a sharp increase of the cell mortality values which is likely relates to a marked DNApolB functioning breakdown. Noteworthy, a significant MIE-provoked shortening of the DNA fragments processed, by at least 20% to 25% in length, is also occurred (Table 1). This itself is about to deprive the cell of its usual DNA repair capabilities [1,2,8] which is a reason to expect the tumor growth to get limited [3,9]. Thus, the MIE-dependent formation of these “size invalid”, DNA repair insufficient, DNA sequences means an entirely new element in paramagnetic anti-cancer paradigm.
|Isotopes||*DNApolB Expression Patterns||*LC50, µg/mL|
|Catalytic activity, [3H]DNA cpm/mg protein||DNA chain size range, n|
|Magnetic||[25Mg2+], 15.0 µg/mL||14,810||190 - 240||8.40|
|[43Ca2+], 15.0 µg/mL||20,330||180 - 220||5.33|
|[67Zn2+], 15.0 µg/mL||17,086||190 - 230||17.85|
|Non-magnetic||[24Mg2+], 15.0 µg/mL||42,660||270 - 320||103.20|
|[40Ca2+], 15.0 µg/mL||51,345||270 - 320||166.42|
|[64Zn2+], 15.0 µg/mL||48,044||280 - 310||197.86|
Table 1: DNA repair key enzyme and cell viability affected by stable metal isotopes in retinoblastoma ex vivo culture.
The applied medicinal significance of these data looks promising due to the followings: (a) the MIE ion-radical mode [4–7] does not allow the most members of DNA Polymerases diversity (a, ?, d) to get operated this way since the electron transfer distances in their catalytic sites are too long to make a “magnet” manifesting its MIE [1,3,5]; while (b) DNApolB is a perfect target for MIE-ions considering this enzyme active site 3D-structure [4,7]. Besides, (c) the above specified “magnets” were proven of being the substantial subjects for a cancer targeted delivery conducted with the low-toxic amphiphilic nanocationites [5,11]. Our ex vivo RB culture provides an advantage compared to the RB standard cell lines like WERI or Y79 for a whole body immune and endocrine systems are capable of making an unpredictable impact on epigenetic status of cancer. So the paramagnetic modulators of a DNApolB function deserves to get incorporated into retinoblastoma chemotherapy strategies.
Thus, a preclinical test step for 25Mg2+ - MIE has been confirmed lately to complete the AML related arsenal of medicinal isotopes with the Magnesium-25 enriched, so to say “easy-to-permit”, Mg-containing officinal drug forms . In this case, a mode of the isotope anti-tumor action, caused by deprivation of the AML-specific DNA repair capabilities, has unambiguously determined by a number of circumstances including an MIE-allowing structural uniqueness of the DNA Polymerase Beta [4,5], hyperexpression of this target enzyme in AML  and by the ion-radical manner of the 25Mg2+ - induced dysfunction of the tartget [2-5]. Considering the routine magnesium pharmacology profile, there is nothing obscure about the resulted Magnesium-25 safety profile too. Therefore, this translational research program does not require a full-scale safety doubting testing once the algorithm proposed is engaged (Figure 1).
There is no reason not to extrapolate this algorithm onto any other MIE-sensitive tumor chemotherapy including a novel RB treatment strategy [2,8]. To support this statement, a variable data on 25Mg2+ - MIE expression in RB cells might be taken into account [1-3,8,10] (Figure 2). All these data, along with our original results presented here (Table 1 and Figure 1) are no doubt in a favor to a remarkable pharmacological potential of bivalent metal paramagnetics as the safe-nefficient anti-retinoblastoma agents.
All Published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved. iMedPub LTD Last revised : January 20, 2019